Operators on OTAs — Marketing Channels or Politicians?

Operators would like OTAs to come clean on how the businesses are run, but some think there are more useful ways to engage

Reading Time: 2 minutes 38 seconds

OTA leadership are perhaps becoming too practiced at responding to operators’ questions, with one describing them as “five politicians on the stage, avoiding answering the questions that were asked.”

Ian MacPhee of Prince of Whales continued: “I have tremendous respect for the fact that these folks run large companies with lots of shareholders to answer to but we want to know the answers.”

The main issues McPhee has with OTAs are a lack of control, costs per booking, and the lack of customer ownership.

However, these are all areas where OTA leadership has been drilled hard. They are fully media trained and know their answers by rote. They know exactly what to expect and — unlike most politicians — are prepared.

Arival 360 | SAN DIEGO 2024

30 September – 3 October 2024

Insider Pro Access Members Save 20%

THE event of the year for solutions-focused In-Destination Experience
creators and sellers

Save up to $660 with the Spring Savings ticket

Learn More

Kevin O’Neil, CEO of Destiny Water Adventures and less-than-Awkward Watersport Guy, struggled to see the issue with OTAs. O’Neil sees them as a marketing tool to be turned off and on when needs be.

“OTAs are a tool,” O’Neil said. “You can sell your products on there, you can sell part of your products on there, you can sell none of your products on there, you can get into the mix and dogfight with them. There’s plenty of David and Goliath stories out there. 

“You don’t need OTAs to sell your products and, I don’t care what vertical you’re in, there’s plenty of ways for you to reach your customers and you don’t if you don’t like what an OTA is doing, it’s very simple — don’t freakin use them.”

However, O’Neil said that Destiny Water Adventures only sees 15–20% of its revenue come through OTAs.

“They are unnecessary evil,” Sadie Sumner from Fat Tire Tours said. “If you look at your competitors and your competitors are harnessing OTAs you can’t just turn them off completely. 

“We just have to realize that OTAs are there to make money and to own the customer, and they market themselves as a distribution channel.

”Yet during Covid, we saw that GetYourGuide locked product changes due to quality control. It was really because they reduced their staff and yet we reduced our staff and we were working 10 times harder to get product changes because of Covid restrictions out to our customers. So they ceased to exist as a distribution channel. 

“It’s crazy that they’re able to market themselves as that and to get up here and talk around the questions. What I want from them in the future is transparency, honesty: ‘Yes, we are here to own the customer. We’re not just a distribution channel. We’re here to make money.’”

So What Do You Think? An Operator Town Hall will run at Arival 360 Online on Thursday, February 242022

To access more interviews and watch curated content from the Arival conference, join us online

Arival 360 San Diego attendees have full access to Arival 360 Online. Tickets are $299 for non-members and Pro Access members can attend for free

Become a Pro Access member and get easy access to all of Arival’s online events, including Arival 360 San Diego, and our complete library of premium research and Arival guides for operators for a full year, starting at just $179 for small operators


Sign up to receive insights tailored for the in-destination industry as well as updates on Arival.

Sign Up
Print Friendly, PDF & Email


already a member?

Lost your password?


Become an Arival Insider

Included in Free Membership

Included in Arival Pro Membership

The Arival on-demand video library archive
Access to the entire library of over 150 video sessions and webinars

Short, digestible research & trends reports delivering insights into our industry, such as The Tour Operator Outlook for 2021.

Arival.travel articles
Topical articles about marketing, tech, operator business and operator stories in all areas of tours, activities & attractions & experiences

Job board access
Find a job from our regular listings, post a resume to the talent network and learn strategies from the job resources articles

New webinars
Helpful, instructional sessions covering subjects such as Mastering Facebook Ads, Grow Your Business and How To Work With OTAs — topics to help advance your business.

Discounts on all Arival in-person events
20% Discount on all Arival in-person events (save up to $300)* based on business type

Arival ProShield – Insurance program
Access to tailored insurance solutions by Granite Insurance is available exclusively for Arival Insider Pro Access Members. Insider Pro Access Members also have access to a suite of resources from Granite Insurance including templates, forms and other informative documents.

Insiders Pro Access member exclusive webinars
Paid membership-only webinars to deepen your understanding of important industry topics.

Job postings & talent directory
Post jobs & connect with candidates most applicable to your business.

Private roundtables to connect, learn and engage
Small, focused and intimate discussions exclusive to Arival Insider Pro Access members.

Full access to Arival’s library of in-depth reports
Up to date, deep analysis of tourism topics ranging from Self-guided Tours to Sales & Distribution Trends and Outlooks, based on the data that defines the industry.

The latest on-demand videos
Over 350+ on-demand videos featuring hot topics in tours, activities & attractions

Insider discounts in digital marketing, tech, e-learning, and more
Save money on additional tools, services and learnings you need to run your business. Exclusive to paid members.

Membership Overview

At Arival, we believe travel can make the world a better place. Our mission is to establish and inspire a diverse community of individuals and companies in the In-destination Industry by providing opportunities to gain insight, share knowledge and build connections. To make it possible for true collaboration, creativity, innovation, and idea exchange to thrive, we are committed to facilitating a welcoming and respectful community for all. This Conference Code of Conduct shares our community expectations and applies to all attendees, employees, exhibitors, speakers, sponsors, volunteers, and other participants at Arival- produced and sponsored events. We empower all participants in our community to actively engage in creating a friendly, inclusive and safe environment for all.

Arival’s core values include the following, and create an expectation for conduct at our events and in online community spaces:

We demonstrate a deep respect for human beings inside and outside our company and for the communities in which they live.
We value integrity and strive to consistently interact with others in ways that are authentic, ethical, and fair.
We are dedicated to transparency, committing to clear, open and honest communication.
We actively pursue and advocate for inclusion, diversity and representation of varying cultural backgrounds, perspectives and ideas

Arival welcomes people from all cultural backgrounds, and does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, creed, gender (including pregnancy, perceived pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, or related medical conditions), gender identity, religion (including religious dress and grooming), marital status, domestic partner status, genetic information, age, national origin or ancestry, military or veteran status, sexual orientation, physical or mental disability, or any other basis protected by federal, state, or local laws.

Accordingly, participants must refrain from displaying any demeaning, harassing, aggressive, or intimidating behavior or materials that would interfere with others’ experience and participation in our community.

If you witness or are subjected to inappropriate or disruptive behavior or have any other concerns, notify an Arival staff member as soon as possible.

Inappropriate or disruptive behavior will not be tolerated. Arival reserves the right to refuse entry to or remove any party from any event or community space at any time when participation or behavior create a disruption or hinder the event or enjoyment of the event by other participants. All determinations are at the sole discretion of Arival, and the decision of the Arival team will be final. Severe breaches of this Conference Code of Conduct may result in disqualification from participating in future events. Individuals expelled due to violating this Conference Code of Conduct will not be eligible for a refund or other consolation.

If you have questions regarding this Conference Code of Conduct or its implementation, please contact us at [email protected].