What Operators Get Wrong About TikTok (And How to Fix It)

At least 71% of European TikTok users say they’re likely to book a holiday based on recommendations they’ve seen on the platform. And according to TikTok Marketing Science, 70% of users report booking a trip or activity after seeing TikTok content, with 52% completing that booking within a week.

Meanwhile, Arival research shows operators ranked TikTok among their least used and least effective marketing channels, even as younger travelers put it in a statistical tie with Google for travel discovery.

That gap between where travelers are looking and where operators are showing up is the opportunity. But closing it requires more than repurposing your Instagram content.

Our team manages paid social for tour, activity and attraction brands across North America, and the most common thing we see is operators approaching TikTok with an Instagram mindset. The content is fine. The strategy is fine. It just doesn’t work, because TikTok isn’t built the same way.

Why TikTok Works Differently

The most important thing to understand about TikTok is that it is a discovery platform, not a social network.

On Facebook and Instagram, your feed is built primarily from accounts you already follow. Your social graph shapes what you see. Discovery exists on Instagram’s Explore page, but it’s secondary to the core experience.

TikTok inverts this. The For You Page (FYP) is a recommendation engine that surfaces content from complete strangers based almost entirely on watch behavior, completion rate, and interest signals. Contrary to Instagram or Facebook, follower count is close to irrelevant to how far an individual video travels.

What this means in practice: an operator with 400 followers can publish a video that reaches 100,000 people. That same operator on Instagram would reach a fraction of their existing followers.

For small and mid-sized operators, this is genuinely good news. You do not need to build an audience before your content can perform. You need to make something worth watching.

It also explains why simply cross-posting Instagram Reels to TikTok tends to underperform. Content built for an audience that already knows you doesn’t have to earn attention in the first three seconds. Content on the For You Page does.

Operator Tip: Before filming anything, spend 20 minutes scrolling TikTok as a traveler in your destination would. Search “things to do in [your city].” Notice which videos hold your attention and why. That’s your competitive set, and it’s probably not who you think it is.

ARIVAL 360 | SPOKANE

12-15 Oct 2026

Insider Pro Access Members Save 20%

THE event of the year for creators and sellers of destination experiences to connect, learn & grow.

It’s Your Last Call to Save! Get Your Ticket Today!

Learn More

The Traveler Mindset on TikTok

There’s a second difference that gets less attention but matters just as much: the emotional state your audience is in when your content reaches them.

Engagement on Facebook is driven substantially by reaction. Strong opinions, shared responses, and conversation among people who know each other. Instagram is built around curated self-presentation, which means aspiration and comparison drives the scroll.

TikTok operates on what psychologists call a variable reward schedule. Every swipe delivers an unpredictable outcome: something funny, moving, surprising, or unexpectedly useful. That unpredictability is the mechanism that keeps people watching.

The practical consequence for experience operators is significant. TikTok users are in an open, curious, entertainment-seeking state. They aren’t comparing themselves to your content or reacting to something that annoyed them. They’re waiting to be delighted.

Travel decisions are emotional. People book experiences based on how a place makes them feel: the view, the food, the atmosphere, the moment. TikTok users arrive already primed for exactly that kind of feeling. It’s arguably the most naturally aligned platform in the social landscape for what you’re selling.

Where TikTok Fits in Your Funnel

Setting the right expectations matters here, because unrealistic ones are why many operators try TikTok for six weeks and quit.

Organic TikTok is primarily a top-of-funnel channel. The majority of your views will come from the FYP, not from people who already know you. It’s a powerful discovery tool. It is not a reliable direct-conversion channel on its own.

That said, it’s doing four jobs simultaneously:

• Discovery. Travelers who had no idea your experience existed encounter it on the FYP.
• Research. Roughly 40% of Gen Z now prefer TikTok and social platforms over Google for finding local things to do. Your content is appearing in active planning searches.
• Social proof. Travelers already considering your brand watch real footage of the experience before deciding to book.
• Creative testing. Your organic content tells you which hooks, formats, and angles resonate before you spend a dollar on advertising.

That last one is undervalued. Every video you post is a free test. The videos that earn high completion rates and saves are telling you exactly what your paid creative should look like.

Building a Sustainable Content Practice

Consistency beats virality

The most common failure pattern we see is treating TikTok like a lottery: post something, hope it takes off, disappear for three weeks, repeat.

TikTok’s algorithm learns what your account is about over time and gets progressively better at matching your content to the right viewers. That process requires signals. Plan on 4 to 6 posts per week for at least eight weeks before evaluating whether the channel is working for you.

That’s a real commitment, which is why the schedule you choose matters more than the frequency. A sustainable cadence you can maintain for months will outperform an intense two-week burst every time.

Build around content pillars

Rather than reinventing your approach with every post, organize around four or five recurring themes. For tours, activities and attractions, these consistently perform:

• Behind-the-scenes. What guests never see: how the experience gets set up, the morning routine before opening, how your guides prepare. This feels exclusive, and exclusive content earns saves.
• Educational and planning content. “What to know before you visit,” best times to come, what to wear, hidden details most visitors miss. This category performs unusually well in TikTok search, because it matches the intent of someone actively planning.
• Guest stories and reactions. Real visitor moments, first-person POV, genuine surprise. This is your strongest social proof, and it’s the content most likely to be worth amplifying with paid later.
• Entertainment and personality. Humor and relatability. Ryanair built one of the most-followed brand accounts on the platform by leaning into self-deprecating jokes about common complaints. You don’t have to go that far, but showing personality outperforms showing polish.
• Trend participation. When a trending sound or format genuinely fits, use it. When it doesn’t, skip it. Research suggests 93% of consumers want brands to keep up with culture, but 32% find forced trend participation embarrassing. The instinct to sit one out is usually correct.

Production quality is not the constraint

This is worth stating plainly because it’s the objection we hear most often from operators: you do not need a production crew, and high production value can actually work against you.

In our client work, smartphone-shot, guide-led, unpolished content consistently outperforms professionally produced brand video on TikTok. Broader industry testing supports this; UGC-style content tends to outperform polished brand assets by roughly 22%.

The reason is straightforward. Polish signals “advertisement,” and TikTok users have finely tuned radar for that. Content that looks like a person filmed it on a phone reads as trustworthy before a single word is spoken.

Operator Tip: Have your guides film 30 seconds of raw footage on their phones once a week. No script, no setup. That library becomes your content engine, and it costs you nothing.

TikTok as a Search Engine

TikTok search volume has grown roughly 150% year over year since 2024. Increasingly, your content isn’t just competing on the For You Page; it’s competing in search results when someone types “things to do in Savannah” or “best kayak tour Oahu.”

TikTok indexes four separate layers of your content for search, and most operators optimize only one of them:

• Spoken audio. TikTok automatically transcribes what you say. Stating your primary keyword out loud in the first five seconds is one of the highest-leverage things you can do, and almost nobody does it.
• On-screen text. Indexed separately from audio. Keep it short, high-contrast, and visible for at least three seconds.
• Captions. Write them as sentences that include the terms travelers actually search, not just a string of tags. “What to expect on our sunrise volcano tour on Maui” beats “☀️🌋 #maui.”
• Hashtags. Use two to three specific, intent-matching tags plus one broader trending tag. They’re context signals that help the algorithm categorize you, not a ranking hack.

Think about the exact phrases a traveler would type. Then build content that answers those phrases directly. A video titled around “best time to visit [attraction] to avoid crowds” will keep earning views months after you post it.

Community management is an algorithm signal

Responding to comments quickly, especially in the first few hours after posting when distribution is most active, generates engagement signals that feed back into your reach.

TikTok’s Duet and Stitch features are particularly underused by operators. Stitching a guest’s reaction video and adding your own context builds social proof while signaling to the algorithm that you’re an active participant in the community. Both effects compound.

When and How to Add Paid

Once you have three months of consistent organic content and you know what’s working, paid amplification becomes worth considering. A few things we’ve learned running TikTok ads for experience brands:

Spark Ads are the format that matters most. Spark Ads let you boost an existing organic post, either your own or a creator’s with permission, while keeping the native post experience intact. Engagement lands on the original video, the existing comment section builds credibility, and it still reads as a real post rather than an ad. TikTok reports that 87% of its top 200 performing Spark Ads featured creator content.

For experience brands specifically, a guest’s authentic reaction video boosted as a Spark Ad tends to outperform a produced brand ad. It delivers social proof in the most credible possible form: a real person who actually did the thing.

Go broader than feels comfortable. Operators coming from Meta advertising instinctively build narrow, tightly segmented audiences. On TikTok, that usually hurts performance. The algorithm uses watch behavior to find your audience, which means your creative is effectively doing the targeting. Broad audiences consistently outperform narrow ones on both cost and conversion rate.

Leave new campaigns alone for the first few days. TikTok’s system needs an uninterrupted learning period to find your audience. Editing budgets, bids, or targeting during the first three to five days resets that process. If you need to make a change, pause and duplicate rather than editing a live campaign.

Budget for creative refresh, not just media. TikTok burns through creatives faster than any other platform. An ad that’s performing well can decline sharply within a week or two at meaningful spend. Plan on rotating in fresh variants continuously rather than treating creative as a one-time production cost.

ARIVAL 360 | BILBAO

13-15 April 2027

Insider Pro Access Members Save 20%

THE event of the year for the European in-destination experiences industry

Save up to €850 with an Autumn Advantage Ticket as an Insider Pro Member!

Learn More

Getting Started

If TikTok has been on your list but never at the top of it, here’s a realistic on-ramp:

Weeks 1–2. Audit the footage you already have. Most operators have far more raw material than they realize. Start filming short, unpolished videos around two or three of the content pillars above.

Weeks 3–8. Post four to six times per week. Watch completion rate and saves rather than follower count; those are the metrics that tell you whether content is landing.

Month 3 and beyond. Identify your top organic performers and consider boosting them as Spark Ads. Keep the organic cadence going regardless.

TikTok rewards operators who show up consistently and show their experience honestly. That’s a meaningful advantage for tours, activities and attractions, because what you sell is already visual, emotional, and inherently interesting. Most of the work is just pointing a camera at it and getting out of the way.

The operators winning on TikTok right now aren’t the ones with the biggest budgets. They’re the ones who started, kept going, and let the algorithm figure out the rest.

A version of this article was originally published on Blend’s site. See the original post here.

Take Your Digital Marketing to the Next Level

Learn more about the latest insights in digital marketing at an upcoming Arival event, where industry experts will be leading sessions and workshops on a variety of topics to help operators of tours, activities and attractions level up their digital marketing skills and strategy. 

GET ON THE LIST!

Sign up to receive insights tailored for the in-destination industry as well as updates on Arival.

Sign Up

Header image: Pexels / Mart Production